I'm not so sure that this isn't a trait of being American as opposed to girl. Most of the guys I know would put themselves in the same category of likes. Liking chocolate and ice cream does not make one girly. Even liking really good quality chocolate and ice cream does not make one girly. Just discerning.

I am not the best person to have this conversation with I think. I don't define girly the way most people do. I do feel strongly about my definition though.

I do prefer hot pizza to cold in general.